|
1185.1.29
by Robert Collins
merge merge tweaks from aaron, which includes latest .dev |
1 |
********** |
2 |
ChangeLogs |
|
3 |
********** |
|
4 |
||
5 |
Changelogs have an interesting relation to version control systems. |
|
6 |
They are, for some projects, the primary way of examining history. |
|
7 |
They provide a pattern and standard for writing commit history, which |
|
8 |
may encourage people to enter more details (function names, etc) in a |
|
9 |
systematic way than they otherwise might. The ChangeLog is available |
|
10 |
offline, in tarfiles, or even when the project has been switched into |
|
11 |
a different VCS. |
|
12 |
||
13 |
GNU ChangeLog format is only the most important, not the only such |
|
14 |
file. Debian uses a different format for packages. At a higher |
|
15 |
level, |
|
16 |
||
17 |
At the same time the information there is some redundancy: both the |
|
18 |
ChangeLog and the VCS want to hold the description of what has been |
|
19 |
done, including descriptive text, names of files changed, etc. |
|
20 |
||
21 |
Some people say__ that ChangeLogs are mostly needed because of the |
|
22 |
limitations of CVS (and originally RCS): if it was easy to read the VC |
|
23 |
history when disconnected and at local speed, and if there are atomic |
|
24 |
commits then they might be needed rather less. |
|
25 |
||
26 |
__ http://gcc.gnu.org/ml/gcc/2004-06/msg00270.html |
|
27 |
||
28 |
There should be hooks called to create the log message template and |
|
29 |
before committing it. These might, for example, populate it with |
|
30 |
space for per-file comments, or check that it is in the right format. |